GORT

Reviews

Is There A Generally Accepted Mulligan Rule For Edh?

Di: Everly

Do you use Partial Paris mulligans? - Commander (EDH) - The Game - MTG ...

What mulligan rules does your playgroup use?

While my main shop doesn’t hold official tourneys, we still have a fairly strong edh presence there. We use the partial paris mulligan method (draw your normal seven, you can

To take a mulligan, a player shuffles the cards in their hand back into their library, draws a new hand of cards equal to their starting hand size, then puts a number of those cards

The current accepted EDH Mulligan rule is a little bit different than the normal rule. It works as follows: You draw the initial 7 cards, and then choose whether or not to

Magic has mulligan rules in its official rules documentation, so my group just uses those and builds decks such that they generally draw playable hands within a reasonable number of

  • What Mulligan Rule do you use?
  • Help us refine a House Rule?
  • Is there a clear line between EDH and cEDH?

My group is pretty casual with mulligan’s. Decks are built and tuned fairly well so it’s not usually an issue and mulligan’s rarely happen, but we give unlimited free mulligan’s just so the one or two

London Mulligan is official!

Before everyone flips out, keep in mind that it’s the Commander Rules Committee that maintains the rules for EDH, not WotC. Until early 2016, EDH had a different Mulligan rule than other

This is the official rule for a multiplayer (I.e. 3 or more players) game. And it is much better than any of the older EDH mulligan rules I’ve heard of, some of which were essentially like casting

EDH Recommendations and strategy content for Magic: the Gathering Commander

If you’re playing with random, you’re accepting that you should expect things you don’t agree to. Anything beyond „general power level“ / game duration is definitely not cool for that. If you

I’m already aware of certain Commander spin-offs like 1v1, Duel, and of course Wizard’s Brawl format, I’m mostly looking to find which of those options (or any others) are generally accepted

It’s only greedy deck building relative to what would be a well-built deck for standard mulligan rules though. Either players only play in this playgroup with these rules, in which case building

  • In EDH Mulligan — MTG Q&A
  • Likelihood of Mulligan Rules ChangeMulligan official rules
  • Question about mulligans.
  • Has anyone tried the new mulligan rule?

Though in the same regard, if you have to constantly mulligan 3 or more times to start the game, I would suggest you would need more lands in your deck. I had a playgroup with the same

to be clear, one free mulligan is the official rule for all multiplayer formats. i’ve played with people who allow infinite free mulligans. i’m not generally a fan of this, although if somebody attests to

EDH uses regular mulligan rules now, so if the mulligan rules change then they’ll automatically change for EDH UNLESS the RC makes a change for EDH. Thats for multiplayer games. Is

If there are rules/topics to talk about, we generally discuss them before individual cards. When it comes to potential bannings, someone (generally me, but not always) opens up

My FLGS uses the Ontario mulligan for EDH, I have been so used to this London is a very big change. For those who don’t know the Ontario mull. Draw 10 Shuffle 3, you mull like normal but

cEDH there is a general acceptance that everyone is going to try to win at all costs as fast as possible. There are no rule 0 conversations, play to win EDH there isn’t that urgency and it

The London Mulligan rule is pretty generous, and in EDH you already get a free one, so if you play enough lands (and aren’t looking for a specific card or combo in your opening hand) it’s

Generally you should mulligan if you have too few or too many lands. Each of these thresholds varies slightly by deck, but generally you wanna mulligan if you have 0, 1, 6, or 7 lands. Fast

So I have heard multiple ways to mulligan for EDH. I think my favorite has been the following: *Step 1: Draw 10 – X cards (where X is the number of times you have mulliganed) keep your

Essentially folks tend to take any number for free mulligans until they have a decent opener. After pointing out at least one specific person for this behavior, I decided to push for

When I play EDH at my LGS, people generally seem to agree that we should all just mulligan until we have a playable hand and keep all seven. I Advertisement Coins. 0 coins. Premium

The point being made here is that commander does not have a format specific mulligan rule. It uses the standard mulligan rules, which includes a free mulligan for multiplayer games.

Posted by u/MCJennings – 35 votes and 70 comments

But by playing with us, you are accepting our house rules and will respect that.“ What you can do is at the start of each game announce the mulligan rule you are playing „no